HEALTH Ebola: Is it better to be fat or muscular if you have Ebola?

Status
Not open for further replies.

tm1439m

Veteran Member
Long story short when a person becomes deathly ill they can lose a considerable amount of weight in a very short period of time.

You could potentially die because you have expended all internal resources and basically your body devours itself trying to heal and stay alive. Of course they would have feeding tubes in your arm but you would still be getting weaker iirc.

Would you be better off with lots of muscle or lots of fat in a situation like this?

In other word would fat or muscle be more life supporting if you were essentially dieing? I am assuming about equal amounts of muscle and fat.

This may sound crazy but I can be fat or muscular by choice in a very short period of time. I have been both multiple times throughout my life going from a 32 inch waist to a 36 inch waist and back is nothing for me to accomplish. Not obese but just with a lot or excess fat hanging around. Not Mr. Olympia but very well toned. Probably a weight swing of around 20 to 30 pounds. I am currently working on losing weight and toning up. My wife hates me because I can transform from either in a matter of a few weeks. I have done it many times. I love food. Sugar and cheese in particular and most things containing them. I know when I am going to get fat and when I am going to get trim.

I am currently getting trim because of a few projects that will require lots of endurance and strength. Fat slows you down.

With this Ebola thing going on I can't help but wonder what would be better for a person if they were to contract this deadly illness? Which would be more life sustaining, fat or muscles?
 

mzkitty

I give up.
I don't think it's going to matter if you contract Ebola.....

A couple of weeks ago, after getting out of the hospital, I came down with some hideous lower GI bug and had to go on Cipro for a week to clean it out. I'm not fat, but was a few pounds overweight. I could not eat a single thing that week, and could only drink ginger ale, of all things, because even water tasted like poison to me. I'm fine now, and the 10 pounds I lost that week has not come back; so I'm thinking it was my fat that sustained me, and burned off. If I got Ebola I would never expect to live though, so for me your question is moot.

Stay away from people and hospitals if you can, what else is there to say? You don't want to get sick period.
 

tm1439m

Veteran Member
I don't think it's going to matter if you contract Ebola.....

A couple of weeks ago, after getting out of the hospital, I came down with some hideous lower GI bug and had to go on Cipro for a week to clean it out. I'm not fat, but was a few pounds overweight. I could not eat a single thing that week, and could only drink ginger ale, of all things, because even water tasted like poison to me. I'm fine now, and the 10 pounds I lost that week has not come back; so I'm thinking it was my fat that sustained me, and burned off. If I got Ebola I would never expect to live though, so for me your question is moot.

Stay away from people and hospitals if you can, what else is there to say? You don't want to get sick period.

Well thanks for your opinion but I think you missed the point of this thread.

The question I have is which is more life sustaining fat or muscle?

It would be applicable really in any starvation scenario.
 

mzkitty

I give up.
Well thanks for your opinion but I think you missed the point of this thread.

The question I have is which is more life sustaining fat or muscle?

It would be applicable really in any starvation scenario.

Like I said, it won't matter. First your fat will burn off, then you will start eating muscle. Think about the pics of concentration camp survivors.....
 

Dennis Olson

Chief Curmudgeon
_______________
It's better to have a strong immune system. And I'm going to close this one. No offense, but this really isn't an issue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top