BRKG Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore has collapsed

1/2mv*2 That be a whole lot of force that ship was packing!! Dropping an anchor might just shear everything associated with the anchor system if the anchor hit and lodged on a crack in solid bedrock. Regardless this is bad news all around. Shows how fragile our infrastructures can be. Wonder it someone did their "what-if" analysis on the piers...seems like they need a "Jersey Barrier" like system around bridges piers?

When I look at old railroad bridges out west over rivers with no ship traffic and the size of the bridge piers, proportionally, the RR bridges are huge and look way over-designed compared to the FSK bridge. Just my musings.
Perhaps they dealt with far more weight in the train?
 

medic38572

TB Fanatic
Er.. while I agree with your premise, you might want to check your math! 10,000 tons is 20 million pounds... not 20 quadrillion! (And I might be off by a bit... I didn't feel like counting all the zeroes!)

But I also think it had an awful lot of surface for the wind to catch, and it appeared to be riding high and empty. All factors in a perfect storm)

Summerthyme
I think my math was correct 100000 tons x 2000lbs per ton is 200,000,000 total lbs. I was going by what one of the videos said it weighed.
 
Er.. while I agree with your premise, you might want to check your math! 10,000 tons is 20 million pounds... not 20 quadrillion! (And I might be off by a bit... I didn't feel like counting all the zeroes!)

But I also think it had an awful lot of surface for the wind to catch, and it appeared to be riding high and empty. All factors in a perfect storm)

Summerthyme
Think this was kinda like Radar ( or was it Klinger) ordering 12 dozen gross. That’s 144 144’s
 

jward

passin' thru
I posted Sal Mercogliano's video this morning-#126- a world known voice not only in geopolitics and maritime history, but a mariner and firefighter himself- he briefly goes over the incident video and details the physics at play - it raised no questions in his mind that a loss of power resulted in a collision and catastrophic loss of the bridge, so - since we can't all be expert on everything, all we can do is find those various people who are reliable voices in their field before crisis occurs, so that we can know who's opinion to value after. And hone our discernment.

Most of us get that we're already in a proxy war and that this kind of action is exactly what a putin or mossad might leave as a lil message to back the hell up before it was too late- but all we can do is follow the facts, and thus far the facts do not support the concerns that an outside agent caused this accident.

Now, we wait to see what led to that loss of power and see what further story is told by a purusual of those facts.



I picked up on all that. And I'm not disparaging his views nor his expertise, but just because something could be an accident; with all that is going on in the world today, doesn't mean it IS an accident.

Not to argue, but I remember a time when 99.99% of the American people took 911 at face value, and it took well over a decade for the majority, and it is now a majority, to stop believing what they had been fed in the official story.

I've been following the over 129 food plants, farms, etc that have been burned down in this country, all the oil refineries that have "had accidents", all the MAJOR train derailments, all since the obamaista's got back in. Much of that has been sabotage, no doubt about it.

And we are being invaded at the same time by over 10 million and that is no accident. This country is under assault.

This could have been an accident, this could have been deliberate.

I don't accept any major damage like this as just happenstance until it is proven as such, not under the present conditions. Buick Electra posted a very good analysis of WHY this would be a perfect act of sabotage, and very very hard to prove.

Hard to prove unless someone can find a link between the Captain and some 3 letter, which also includes the Russians as possibilities. As I mentioned above this could also be a message, and if it happened to be such, the goofballs at the top will never admit it.
 

jward

passin' thru
John Ʌ Konrad V reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
***SPECIAL ODD LOTS***

@tracyalloway and I talk with @mercoglianos
about the disaster in Baltimore.

-How it happened
- What the effects will be on fright
- What the next steps that regulators will be taking
- Who will bear the cost
++


Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart

There's nobody who has a better instant grasp on this stuff than @mercoglianos. If you haven't watched his video from this morning, narrating the footage of the crash, I highly recommend it



bloomberg.com
Sal Mercogliano on the Baltimore Bridge Collapse
Tracy Alloway, Joe Weisenthal
1–2 minutes

The Dali container vessel after striking the Francis Scott Key Bridge that collapsed into the Patapsco River in Baltimore, Maryland on Tuesday.
Photographer: Al Drago/Bloomberg

Listen to Odd Lots on Apple Podcasts
Listen to Odd Lots on Spotify
Subscribe to the newsletter

On March 26th, a massive container ship called the Dali ploughed into Baltimore's Francis Scott Key Bridge, a major overpass just outside the city's port. The collision caused the bridge to dramatically collapse, sparked a search and rescue mission for survivors. It also cut off a busy shipping lane in and out of the Port of Baltimore. So what do we know about the collision? And what could the impacts of the latest maritime disaster actually be? On this emergency episode of Odd Lots, we speak to Sal Mercogliano, a professor at Campbell University and the host of the What Is Going On With Shipping? show on YouTube, about what we know so far.

 

jward

passin' thru
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender

The Department of Homeland Security have released their Initial Findings regarding the Incident this morning in Baltimore, Maryland in which a Cargo Ship rammed into and caused the Collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge; with the Report stating that at the time of the Crash, the Ship was being Piloted by a Veteran-Harbor Pilot who knew the nearby Waterways and that the Ship had notified the Maryland Department of Transportation that they had Fully-Lost Propulsion and Control as they were Departing from Port, with them heading Directly towards the Bridge.

1711507959616.jpeg
 

jed turtle

a brother in the Lord
I had that same thought. What if the Captain was on the Russian side of things.
Indeed. It is the Russians that have already been attacked by the west trying to destroy the Crimean bridge and the Nordstream pipeline. And the West supplied muderous shelling of Ukrainian civilians who refused to acknowledge the new western usurpers in Kiev authority to force them to give up their language.
 

Buick Electra

TB2K Girls with Guns
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender

The Department of Homeland Security have released their Initial Findings regarding the Incident this morning in Baltimore, Maryland in which a Cargo Ship rammed into and caused the Collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge; with the Report stating that at the time of the Crash, the Ship was being Piloted by a Veteran-Harbor Pilot who knew the nearby Waterways and that the Ship had notified the Maryland Department of Transportation that they had Fully-Lost Propulsion and Control as they were Departing from Port, with them heading Directly towards the Bridge.

View attachment 467357
WOW! That was QUICK! Fastest I've ever seen DHS move!
 

medic38572

TB Fanatic
WOW! That was QUICK! Fastest I've ever seen DHS move!
I listened to the police radio traffic prior to the crash. And that is what dispatch was telling the officers attempting to block both sides of the bridge. One officer was waiting for another to get to him so he could warn the workers on the bridge and baaaam he told him to send everyone as the bridge had collapsed. sucks.
 

jward

passin' thru
I chose not to listen to the scanner or the recordings of the initial calls- but overall my impression is a lot of respect for those workers who stayed on the job, and a bit of surprise, as my image of the baltimore area was not a positive one, before today.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
Formulamultiply the mass value by 2000

Mass100,000 x 2000=200,000,000 you are multiplying it by 200
LOL! Read your original post! Your math was (apparently) correct. Your way of the expressing the total was misleading, at best.

As POD said, it's like ordering 144 gross. You put a ship at sea that weighs 200,000,000 MILLION... and i I want to see it float!

Summerthyme
 

medic38572

TB Fanatic
LOL! Read your original post! Your math was (apparently) correct. Your way of the expressing the total was misleading, at best.

As POD said, it's like ordering 144 gross. You put a ship at sea that weighs 200,000,000 MILLION... and i I want to see it float!

Summerthyme
Mass 100,000 tons x 2000 lbs per ton === you guessed it 200,000,000 million lbs. :D hope that is better!
 

medic38572

TB Fanatic
I chose not to listen to the scanner or the recordings of the initial calls- but overall my impression is a lot of respect for those workers who stayed on the job, and a bit of surprise, as my image of the baltimore area was not a positive one, before today.
I listen to the scanner all the time. Last night it went off when this happened, BUT , I didnt look at it because every night at the same time in Indianapolis, Indiana every night, I mean every night, they have a shooting or OIS. Indianapolis has to be the most dangerous city in the US.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
I listened to the police radio traffic prior to the crash. And that is what dispatch was telling the officers attempting to block both sides of the bridge. One officer was waiting for another to get to him so he could warn the workers on the bridge and baaaam he told him to send everyone as the bridge had collapsed. sucks.
She's talking about the report. Apparently implying a whitewash...

It's simple... this is a PRELIMINARY report, pretty much describing the incident from a hundred foot overview. Simple facts... they had an experienced pilot aboard, they lost power and control, and immediately issued a Mayday... which was passed on with amazing speed, and saved many lives.

Now, there were likely a dozen or more surviving witnesses, and their stories apparently were close enough (albeit from different vantage points) that normally suspicious investigators found the story and timeliness reasonable and believable. Remember... as a map posted above shows, these ships are traced in minute detail... speed, GPS positions, actually path across the water.

But now there's going to be a much more in depth investigation to find out HOW and WHY they lost power. We may not see that report for months... and while unlikely, that's where any potential criminal charges could come from.

Looking like a tragic accident to me...

Summerthyme
 

Macgyver

Has No Life - Lives on TB
I listen to the scanner all the time. Last night it went off when this happened, BUT , I didnt look at it because every night at the same time in Indianapolis, Indiana every night, I mean every night, they have a shooting or OIS. Indianapolis has to be the most dangerous city in the US.
I've been noticing that Indianapolis thing almost every night as well.
 

jward

passin' thru
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
Transportation Secretary In Response To Bridge Disaster: Maybe Some Bridges Were Made By Racists

"If an underpass was constructed such that a bus, carrying mostly black and Puerto Rican kids, was designed too low for it to pass by, that obviously reflects racism that went into those design choices.

I don't think we have anything to lose by confronting simply reality."

Besides sanity perhaps?

Source: C-SPAN
View: https://twitter.com/MarioNawfal/status/1772830282036429187?s=20
 

hiwall

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Somewhere I saw comments about a 14mph crosswind at the time of the accident. The ship and those stacks of cargo containers presents a huge sail area. If the containers were empty the ship would be riding higher in the water presenting even more sail area.

But I also think it had an awful lot of surface for the wind to catch, and it appeared to be riding high and empty.
IF the ship was "light" wouldn't it take on ballast so it would ride at its optimal depth?
 

vector7

Dot Collector

John Deere Girl

Veteran Member
View: https://twitter.com/ChuckCallesto/status/1772824870469902406


Chuck Callesto

@ChuckCallesto
Subscribe

BREAKING NOW:
⚠️
Chesapeake Bay Bridge in Annapolis, MD south of The Francis Scott Key Bridge that COLLAPSED after bring hit by a container ship has been SHUT DOWN... DEVELOPING.. As of now the bridge is CLOSED TO ALL TRAFFIC due to weather conditions or "SAFETY" concerns.. Is this a strange coincidence or something much much more?
https://twitter.com/ChuckCallesto/status/1772824870469902406/photo/1
 

medic38572

TB Fanatic
1711519851977.png

Only other thing I could find is coastal flooding

Official updates
From National Weather Service · Last updated 8 hours ago
Official updates
COASTAL FLOOD ADVISORY REMAINS IN EFFECT UNTIL 3 PM EDT WEDNESDAY

* WHAT...Up to one foot of inundation above ground level in low
lying areas due to tidal flooding.

* WHERE...Shoreline in Southern Baltimore County and the city of
Baltimore.

* WHEN...Until 3 PM EDT Wednesday, especially around the time of
high tide.

* IMPACTS...At 3.5 feet, flooding is occurring at the end of
Thames Street in Baltimore. Water covers the promenade in the
Inner Harbor in multiple locations. At 3.0 feet, water begins
encroaching upon yards in the Bowleys Quarters area.

* ADDITIONAL DETAILS...Tides two to two and a half feet above
normal. The next high tide at Fort McHenry Baltimore is at 8:34
PM and 8:52 AM.
 

homecanner1

Veteran Member
I look at it this way, Sparrows was the main shipbuilding facility of WW2, it was the powerhouse Mac Daddy with Beth Steel that helped give us that win by dominating the Pacific.

Imagine instead a strafe run on Sparrows Point back then and taking the entire harbor out of commission and our warfooting capability.

IF this was not accidental, someone still masterminded a crippling blow.

Matt Bracken has been raving last four weeks about Chinese chips in the crane facilities at our ports to cripple our on/off container loading.

That a boatload of doofus pajeets (learned a new slur this week!) have somehow pulled off a caper that 1943 Berlin would have salivated over is astounding in itself. This IS the Black Swan event. And we are only beginning to grasp the shockwaves.

One of which is the Haitian flotillas we are being warned about, they won't be getting dumped off courtesy of the Coasties picking up 'drifting dinghie loads' to that port and 'sanctuary city'. Sorry B-More.

It will jostle the UAW rank and file with auto sector shipping derailed there. Might impact some Biden voters that work in those facilities.

And if it stops the 'spice' flowing in the form of fentanyl or heroin, that's also a positive in spite of the tragic.

I don't foresee the bridge getting rebuilt either, not that we can't rally previous can do spirit again. But do we want a bridge there or a tunnel?

They will rig a passenger ferry system for local dock workers. Workarounds will abound.

But when the 3rd or 4th bridge or lock system or major ship terminal marine navigation hub get trashed, then plausible denial/human error will no longer suffice. Expect more
 
Last edited:

mecoastie

Veteran Member
View: https://twitter.com/ChuckCallesto/status/1772824870469902406

Chuck Callesto
@ChuckCallesto
Subscribe

BREAKING NOW:
⚠️
Chesapeake Bay Bridge in Annapolis, MD south of The Francis Scott Key Bridge that COLLAPSED after bring hit by a container ship has been SHUT DOWN... DEVELOPING.. As of now the bridge is CLOSED TO ALL TRAFFIC due to weather conditions or "SAFETY" concerns.. Is this a strange coincidence or something much much more?
View: https://twitter.com/ChuckCallesto/status/1772824870469902406/photo/1
They close it during high wind and weather events. I am not seeing a closure listed on any of the MD transportation sites.
 

Slydersan

Veteran Member
They close it during high wind and weather events. I am not seeing a closure listed on any of the MD transportation sites.
Yeah I didn't hear anything about THAT bridge being closed this morning on the local TV/radio news. And I'm sure it would have been highlighted due to the current "sensitivities". We did have a rain band come through early this AM, but it wasn't windy at all where I was.

Side note - my commute home doubled, from 30 mins to 1 hour. "Most" people were actually somewhat polite on the roads yesterday afternoon. Hopefully that will last.

It is weird looking in the direction of the bridge and not seeing anything. I'm not "from" the area but I've lived here a long time and I get it when people get interviewed and almost get emotional about it. It would be like if there is a mountain near you, you see it a hundred times a day, and then one day it just disappears. You do a double-take, then a triple-take, because it "should" be there but isn't. Very disorienting. I must have seen 100+ people yesterday evening on my way home, anywhere there was a little hill or overpass, normally with a view of the bridge, standing there taking pictures/video, with their kids, grandmas, etc. I don't think most people can grasp how emotional people are over this.
 

Melodi

Disaster Cat
A breaking news headline on Sky.com (UK)is that:

"Investigators Exame Whether Dirty Fuel Led To Bridge Collapse"

That's it; for now, if you click on the ongoing story, this part still needs to be updated. I suspect it will be in a few minutes.

But if this report is accurate, it could be a game changer.

Breaking news headline is on the main page here at:

On-going story is here...
 

mecoastie

Veteran Member
I had 24.5 yrs in the USCG as well, & I concur with your judgment. This morning I told my wife that it was no accident.
The crew could have taken manual control of the engines/red.gears/steering. With the flip of a breaker they could have disabled the horn. Muslim crew?
RT 1min
View: https://twitter.com/Bullcrap59/status/1772690117066404328?t=P1szWm8e-iKrawkmnIf52A&s=19
I will take a stab at it.
The video: The ship was a container ship not a tanker. A pilot boat doesnt follow a ship. It goes and picks up a pilot once the are offshore or drops a pilot off to an incoming vessel. A pilot boat would have done nothing to stop or change that accident. The tugs were released after the vessel got into the waterway. Again they most likely werent required.
The commentary: It takes time to get the emergency steering activated. The requirement is 60 secs to go from 15 degrees port to 15 degrees starboard or vice versa. So to go from 0 to 15 would take about 30 secs if the space was fully manned and ready to go. It most likely wasnt manned which takes time for crew to get there and activate it. That ship is a direct drive, there are no reduction gears and to my knowledge there is no way to take manual control of reduction gears.

It is basic details like this that make me question their knowledge of commercial vessels and port operations.
 
Top